Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Im Black, You're White, Whos Innocent?

I think Shelby Steele brings an interesting perspective to the issue of race. I like how he elaborates the fact that racial tension is the result of by a power struggle. His Innocence Vs. Guilt idea was something I had not thought to much about but could relate to. I think that some of the ideas get a lost in his terminology at some points however. I think some of his examples were a little on the weak side, namely his reference to the Crosby show. I felt like he could have elaborated on his ideas and their correlation to the TV show a little clearer. Its true that the issue of race wasn't ever discussed on the show but the issue of race isn't brought up on any other sit-coms, and I wonder why the fact that the Crosby's would be any different, other than the fact that they were black. On the other hand, I found his personal experiences fascinating. I like the objective tone he seems to use. Hes really good at sticking to a middle ground without dismissing the fact that racism is still an issue. I liked his labeling of Jesse Jackson as a "challenger by instinct and Bargainer by political ambition."I thought it was a better example then the crosby show and gave me a better understanding of what each term meant. All in all I enjoyed the piece, I really enjoy reading about ideas that I haven t heard before. Steele's take on Racism and Class was unique and got me thinking.

2 comments:

  1. I agree that he could have elaborated more about many topics he brought up. I am actually glad to hear that he has written more books on this subject. What if he holds the answers to understanding the difference between the races? These ideas could possibly heal many relationships on both personal and professional levels. Who knows?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I too found his guilt vs innocence ideas new and diffrent than I had heard before in any race relation talks. Steele offered me a new perspective on black and white relations and I also found his theory about the Cosby Show to be weak.

    ReplyDelete